I am a professional
skier. Alas, for every fall I have taken in skiing, my falls in real life
have been far more plentiful and painful. Life can be very slippery, and I
must tell you that your writings have helped me find hope. I was wondering
if you can shed some light on how to navigate our way on the slippery slopes
of life.
With the many slips and falls we witnessed in the figure
skating competition during the recent Turin Olympics, I
thought that perhaps your readers would find this topic
timely.
Respectfully,
What causes us to slip?
Whether on ice or in a nervous moment, why do we lose our balance?
Scientists have posited
various theories to explain the slipperiness of ice. In a recent article in
Physics Today, Why is Ice Slippery? Robert M. Rosenberg, an emeritus professor
of chemistry at Lawrence University, debunks the popular theory that pressure from an object—a skater pushing off, for example—melts
the top layer of ice making it slippery.
Dr. Rosenberg explains
that this assumption is false, because the pressure-melting effect is too
small to account for the slippage that occurs even at much colder temperatures.
The pressure-melting theory also fails to explain why someone wearing flat-bottom
shoes, which has a greater surface area than ice skates and exerts even less
pressure on the ice, can also slip on ice.
Two alternative explanations have
arisen to take the pressure argument's place. One invokes friction: the rubbing
of a skate blade or a shoe bottom over ice heats the ice and melts it, creating
a slippery layer. The other, originally proposed by physicist Michael Faraday
in 1850, holds that the surface of ice has an intrinsic liquid layer. Water
molecules at the ice surface vibrate more than is usual for a solid, because
there are no molecules above them to help hold them in place, and they thus
remain an unfrozen liquid even at temperatures far below freezing. Scientists describe the surface as having liquid properties,
but not fluid.
But both these theories
have their own flaws. According to the friction theory, the question still
remains why ice is slippery even when a person just stands on ice and generates
no heat through friction. According to the latter liquid-layer theory, the
layer is too thin to contribute much to slipperiness except near the melting temperature.
Allow me to submit an
additional dimension. Perhaps the question should be asked the other way around:
Why don’t we always slip on every surface? What causes us to
remain steady on solid ground?
The answer is friction.
When two bodies rub against each other they create a force that resists motion,
thus preventing slipping or falling. But the condition for this is that the
two bodies have to have something in common. If the surface is made of a substance
that has no common denominator with our feet we will be unable to remain steady
on the surface.
Take water for example.
We cannot stand on water because water is not solid, and therefore cannot
support a solid substance that is heavier than water. Thus, on water we don’t
merely slip; we sink, because there is no friction at all between our solid
feet and liquid water. Similarly, the other elements, like fire and air, which
are gaseous in nature, are also unable to supply support for matter that is
more substantial. Earth, by contrast, is a solid substance similar to our
feet, and therefore can support our weight, and causes friction to keep us
balanced.
Ice, which is frozen water,
consists of two paradoxical qualities: On one hand it is a solid, which causes
some friction. Thus, we don’t sink into ice, and with care we can walk on
it. On the other hand, ice is essentially water, albeit not in liquid form
but congealed, yet still water, an entity “foreign” to earth, and therefore
causes a very low level of friction. (Indeed, ice is less dense than the liquid
form, which is why ice floats on water). And if the ice gets too watery we
will be unable to stand firm.
According to the mystics,
land and water are not just two different, but two diametrically opposed entities.
Land reflects “revealed” and conscious experience; water manifests the “hidden”
and unconscious. At opposite ends of the spectrum, land and water represent
the finite and the infinite. These two divergent “universes” have a tenuous
relationship, and must be separated by an intrinsic boundary
lest the water flood
the land. We therefore cannot “walk” on water only on land.
The ultimate objective
is to bridge land and water, the finite and the infinite, matter and spirit.
[For this reason these two worlds were united once in history at the parting
of the sea to empower us with this ability]. This unity, however, is achieved
through a long process of refining the material, finite “land” and acclimating
it to contain the infinite spirit of “water.”
Ice
is an intermediary between water and land. It has something common both with
water and land; it is both solid and liquid. We can walk on ice, yet the ice
is slippery. The slipperiness is caused by the fact that two “worlds” – land
and water – are rubbing against each other, with a bit of friction but not
too much. Ice therefore helps bridge land with the hitherto inaccessible world
of water. Yet care must be taken to not to slip on the ice.
The same is true psychologically.
We can slip whenever we come in contact with an experience that is foreign
to us. When you stay in one place – in your comfort zone – you will not slip.
But neither will you move or grow. When you expose yourself to new ideas,
to fresh options, there is always the risk of losing your footing.
The key is to have just
the right balance between familiarity and movement. Not too much friction
and not too little friction. If you move to fast into new territories, there
may be too much risk of slippage or even drowning. If you move to slowly growth
will be compromised.
So, life is a slippery
slope. The secret to navigation is not just to walk on land, but to glide
gracefully across the ice. Not just step by step, but to reach for the skies
as you scale the mountain.
And above all, to remain
connected above, so as not to fall on the slipper slope below.
Two young men once
visited a small Russian town in mid-winter. They tried to find the ritual
bath (mikveh), and learned that it was at the foot of a steep hill. But the
slope leading down to the bath, they were told, grew so dangerously slippery
in wintertime that no one used it -- no one, that is, except for one very
special chassid who went daily.
The young men were
skeptical, and decided to follow this man the next morning. To their surprise,
he was very old and feeble. Surely, they thought, he cannot possibly make
his way down the slope. But he walked steadily down the icy hill as the young
men, trying to follow, slipped and fell. They watched in awe as he entered
the bathhouse.
Afterwards, they respectfully
asked the elderly man how he had made it down the hill. “When one is connected
above,’’ he said quietly, “he does not fall below.”